UnitedHealthcare delays ED policy; ACR says ‘flawed’ rule may violate patient protection laws

UnitedHealthcare is delaying a new policy that would have denied coverage for some emergency services, including imaging, following intense backlash from patient, doctor and hospital groups.

The insurance giant said Thursday that it would pause implementation of the controversial policy until “at least the end of the national public health emergency period.” Initially, UHC was set to kick-start the rule on July 1, eliminating reimbursement for non-emergency trips to the ED.

A number of organizations have quickly rebuked the insurer, calling for a complete reversal. The American College of Radiology gave its own criticism of the “flawed” policy late Thursday in an email statement to Health Imaging.

“The new UnitedHealthcare emergency department payment policy shifts the responsibility for determining the difference between an emergent or non-emergent situation to the patient before any clinical evaluation,” an ACR spokesperson said, adding such coverage denials may also violate federal patient protection laws, namely the prudent layperson standard.

In a perspective shared Friday, American Hospital Association CEO Rick Pollack said the policy would have a “chilling effect,” scaring people from seeking the care they believe they need.

The hospital advocate warned it would continue to pressure UnitedHealthcare and other commercial health insurers on actions taken against patient health.

“UnitedHealthcare’s action offers a temporary reprieve for patients, and we urge its full and permanent reversal,” Pollack wrote June 11. “There is no justification for these restrictions now or after the public health emergency.”

""

Matt joined Chicago’s TriMed team in 2018 covering all areas of health imaging after two years reporting on the hospital field. He holds a bachelor’s in English from UIC, and enjoys a good cup of coffee and an interesting documentary.

Around the web

RSNA and several other industry societies have shared a new expert consensus document on the significant value of cardiac CT. Echo remains an effective first-line imaging option, the groups wrote, but CT can make a big impact as well. 

"Using AI for tasks like CAC detection can help shift medicine from a reactive approach to the proactive prevention of disease," one researcher said.

Former American Society of Echocardiography president and well-known cardiac ultrasound pioneer Roberto Lang, MD, died at the age of 73. He helped develop 3D echo technology that is now used by care teams on a daily basis.